Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

A Picture is Worth a Thousand Words

1 year post

I wonder why I was charged $3k more than any other patient for a primary rhinoplasty

$21,400
I was charged $3k more than ANY other patient I have spoken with for a primary rhinoplasty. I've spoken with roughly 15 people, several of whom were a revision rhinoplasty, and yet I was still charged more than any of them with no explanation.
I wonder if this could be in any way related to his recent lawsuit that Dr. Nassif filed against him. You can look this up yourself, it is within the public records.

HonestRhinoplastyReview's provider

Donald B. Yoo, MD, FACS

Donald B. Yoo, MD, FACS

Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon

4.5 | 179 Reviews
PROFILE

HonestRhinoplastyReview rating for Dr. Yoo:

Overall rating

Replies (5)

August 6, 2020
Where can I look up the lawsuit between the 2 doctors? I googled it but didn't see anything.
August 7, 2020
It seems to me that Dr. Yoo is named as a co-defendant of a lawsuit against Dr. Nassif which is the primary defendant. The complaint was filed by Eric Klein. https://www.plainsite.org/dockets/30wmi5lxp/superior-court-of-california-county-of-los-angeles/eric-klein-v-paul-nassif-m-d-et-al/
August 10, 2020

This comment was removed at the user's request

August 10, 2020

This comment was removed at the user's request

August 10, 2020
I still cannot find this case number. Can you send me the link? Thank you.
August 10, 2020

This comment was removed at the user's request

August 10, 2020

This comment was removed at the user's request

August 10, 2020
Wow! You're right. See it. Thank you.
August 10, 2020
Dear HonestRhinoplastyReview,
Interesting, that Dr Paul Nassif is suing Dr Donald Yoo. I think this case could be bad publicity for both doctors. More than likely as in most cases, this one will be settled out of court.

About your lip lifting high and showing gum when you smile due to rhinoplasty, that is not unusual. I read some others stories on realself and other review websites where patients complain about upper lip being higher or lower when smiling. In your case, your caudal septal extension graft is above your anterior nasal spine so your upper lip is more elevated when you smile. Or else, your cartilage in your columella was manipulated. Of course, I am guessing only. I am not a doctor.

Your original nose looked fine. If you were deciding on whether to seek primary rhinoplasty and posted on realself, we would have talked you out of it. There was no need. Sorry to see you so upset. Some doctors are just greedy and will do anything.
October 15, 2021
I posted it on his Yelp. He probably pays to have it buried under search results
October 15, 2021
It’s on his Yelp now
October 15, 2021
I went to another doctor and she told me it’s because of all the grafts he’s putting on the tip of the nose. My smile changed as well.
October 15, 2021
No, this is not the case I am referring to. The case I am referring to is case #20SMCV00079
October 15, 2021
In case anyone needs clarification, the lawsuit between Dr. Nassif and Dr. Yoo that I am referring to is case #20SMCV00079
August 7, 2020
Wow, I thought yours was revision. You are right. Why is the quote so high for a primary. I consulted him for a revision, and he knew I had three rhinoplasty surgeries before, and my quote was 19.3K which is 2K lower than yours. Obviously, I didn't go with him, but I still have the quote which was sent to get my 50% deposit payment in advance which would become non-refundable within 48 hours of acceptance. I didn't like his attitude during the consultation, and I disliked his way of doing business transaction by forcing patients paying long before the scheduled surgery. And when I reviewed the pictures on his instagram, I knew no way i would go through having my chest cut opened and getting that kind of nose.
August 29, 2020
I’m so sorry you are going through this. The price for your nose job is too expensive. I was only quoted $18,000. Did you ask him why he charged you that much? it’s not like he has 20 years of experience! There are excellent doctors in LA that don’t even charge that much. By the way I just got a nose job by Dr Charles Lee. I am so happy I chose him. you should consider him for your revision. He seems very knowledgeable and conservative. He gave me exactly what I wanted. I know you are also concerned about your upper lip. In my case, I wanted my upper lip higher because I didn’t have much tooth show, but it made my upper lip fuller. I wish you the best luck with your revision. I heard that making noses smaller is easier than making them bigger.
August 29, 2020
If you don't mind can you post some pics? I'm still looking for a doctor to do my revision. Thanks
August 29, 2020
I’m going to post a review on his site after I’m completely healed and shared my journey, but I can dm you my before and after.
December 9, 2020
Are you guys for real? These prices are nowhere in europe
August 29, 2020
I’m going to post a review on his site after I’m completely healed and shared my journey, but I can dm you my before and after.
August 30, 2020
Yes please do, thanks
September 1, 2020
I have never send messages through RealSelf. I couldn’t send you a pic. Let me try again
September 19, 2020
Can you pls send before and after pics? I have a consultation with dr. Lee but still considering dr. Yoo
September 1, 2020
I have never send messages through RealSelf. I couldn’t send you a pic. Let me try again
1 year post

1.5 Years Post Op, it is the same. NOT swelling.

Again, keeping this completely real and honest. You be the judge.
Look! Listen! Do you love the letter "L"? Do you Love Capital L's? This post is brought to you by the Letter "L'. Why? Because I now have a permanent Capital L on my face, thanks to Dr. Yoo. What about the swelling? What about a "customized artistic individualized approach"? HA! LOL! No. Just, no. Nothing that I was promised in terms of taking my individuality, artistic aesthetic preferences, ethnicity, facial shape, NOTHING was taken into consideration. I was given the EXACT same nose, that everyone else gets. A nose that is a Capital L. I now look older and whiter with significantly more pronounced nasiolabial folds, not to mention the fact that this is NOT the nose I discussed during consultation. Imagine my shock and horror, waking up and getting a nose I did NOT request.
I have spoken to multiple revision specialists with my consultation, and they all knew exactly what I was referring to, agreed that nothing about this nose fit my facial features and it certainly wasn't even close to my desired wish picture, which was 100% reasonable and a mutually agreed upon expected outcome.
The level of unprofessionalism conducted by this surgeon has been shocking, although not surprising given the state of the current healthcare system. I highly encourage EVERYONE to listen to Episode #68 of The Peter Attia Drive Podcast, which details all of the issues within the US Healthcare system and why some surgeons respond the way they do!
Dr. Yoo has not apologized, has not taken my psychological distress into consideration, he has been nothing but arrogant and dismissive, even insinuating that I am mentally unstable. I am not. I am educated, articulate and highly perceptive to the fact that no one has documented their experiences honestly. I have every right to share my experiences in order to help others and advocate for myself.
It is emotionally distressing to write these reviews, since I find reliving the past very traumatic and I get very depressed and distressed having to detail my experiences, so I will keep this sort. I have much more I could say about my experiences but at this time I prefer not to. Especially since they are negative. Here are my updated photos.
One other thing I will mention, is that Dr. Yoo incredulously told me, after I expressed my discomfort, pain and anger for the 3rd time that "No doctor will be able to give you a smaller nose. If you find someone who is capable of giving you that, I'd love to see your nose when it is revised. Let me know, I'd like to know what techniques they used". Why would he be asking me that?! It's incredibly concerning and unprofessional, not to mention completely untrue. Follow up revisionists during my consultation completely understood the original aesthetic I desired and said that this statement was false, that I could indeed have a smaller nose. Some consultations posited that in order to get my wish picture nose, I may have not even needed my rib removed at all. Let. That. Sink. In.
I never cared about having a higher bridge, as stated in my original "receipt" email, which is previously attached and uploaded, all I wanted was a more refined tip. In fact, I stated that I LIKED my original bridge. Let. That. Sink. In.
It was also important to me that my ethnicity be maintained. Both of these desires were completely ignored. This leaves one to wonder, when someone claims to deliver "individualized, customized, artistic" noses, yet EVERY single patient gets a nose that looks like a Capital L....how much individualization goes into this cookie cutter process? Could it be, that perhaps, there is a limited amount of techniques within one's repertoire? Is this why every nose looks the same?
My breathing has been negatively impacted, my smile has been negatively impacted, my mental health has been negatively impacted. My side profile, my 3/4th profile, my life has been negatively impacted. I cannot stress enough how psychologically damaging this has been and how grave the consequences are.
PS: There is currently a lawsuit underway between Dr. Nassif and Dr. Yoo. This is within the public records and you can look it up for yourself. It is public information.
While you review my photos, note how tight my upper lip is, there is so much pressure from my oversized nose, that is pulls my lip up, which makes it thinner and distorts my smile. It also reveals much more of my gum line and my smile is now crooked due to this nose. It also exacerbated my nasiolabial folds and gave me MUCH more pronounced nasiolabial folds than I had before.

Replies (5)

July 31, 2020

This comment was removed at the user's request

August 7, 2020
You are right on. Dismissive and condescending was the impression I got when I had the consultation with him. Whatever I said I wanted was scoffed at and rejected. So I decided not to go with him, and I am glad I didn't choose him.
August 2, 2020
So sorry about your experience. have you decided on a revision surgeon yet?
August 6, 2020
You are such an strong and beautiful person inside and outside.
September 12, 2020
September 12, 2020
She is entitled to her opinion, and she likes her pre-surgery nose far better. How does that make her have "mental issues"? Please don't judge others. By L shape, I think she means it looks like a triangular L, which actually, I think, is not everyone's nose shape
September 12, 2020
September 12, 2020
She did have full lips before. Did you even see the before and after pictures?
September 13, 2020
You sound angry and bitter for no reason.
September 13, 2020
I know right? Why is this person saying, "If I were the doctor, I will give you same response. Crazy !"?seems suspicious
September 13, 2020
I went to their page and they just comment hateful things. Miserable person.
September 18, 2020
I wonder what their real deal is
1 year post

Only a filter hides how big this nose is

HonestRhinoplastyReview
This nose is very large and I have seen several other people with the same nose, even though I wanted a small kpop nose I did not get that. So far none of my photos have been filtered since I believe in transparency, but here is my nose with a filter on this photo. This nose looks bad without a filter. I suspect many people probably filter their rhinoplasty photos to make their nose look better (if they are unhappy with it) rather than be honest and admit that their nose could look significantly better with a revision.
In this day and age, we really cannot trust what we see anymore, as I have noticed many before and after photos use strategic lighting, angles, perhaps even filters. Dr. Subbio has an Instagram where he reveals many of the deceptive secrets behind before/after photos, and I encourage anyone considering surgery to learn from his IG.

Replies (4)

January 30, 2020
I was about to comment that your nose seems to be refined a bit, but then I read that it has been "filtered". What is "filter"? If it makes you feel better. I am not a fan of Dr. Yoo's nose, but at least people don't look at you and wonder what's wrong with your nose. I had to live for almost 20 years with a nose that people wondered about that. Many times, I could not stand looking at myself in the mirror, but after three surgeries, I was so terrified that it could go wrong yet again. So I learned to live with it until now after having talked to my current surgeon and gained some confidence that he could deliver. But it still took me almost a year to go for it (and four more consultations with other surgeons. Dr. Yoo was one of the four).
January 31, 2020
I’m so sorry you have to go through all this. I had augmentation rhino in 2010 and during my consultation asked the surgeon not to insert to big implant as I didn’t want to high nose bridge. He was afraid of ending up with dissatisfying results for me and inserted too small implant which made no difference at all! I decided not to get revision with him and just left everything at it was. But as time went by, the implant began to drop as he also didn’t fix my tip with the cartilage :( can you imagine it?? My nose started to look like I have a hump, even though, originally, I had very straight nose. Recently I found a good surgeon and finally got revision rhino. This time I said that want to make my bridge as high as possible, lol. He said that due to skin lacking on my nose there are some limitations. He also noticed that the tip was downturned and suggested to fix with cartilage. I went to another country for this revision and have no regrets, as got really good results. I’m beyond satisfied as finally have a nose I always wanted to have. So, if you considering revision surgery, I’d highly recommend my surgeon Dr. Seok Jun lee from Regen plastic surgery in Seoul. Good luck!
User Avatar
February 2, 2020
dear i think your nose looks amazing and dr yoo did great job, you have to know that jenny and tzuyu noses are naturally small, not all noses can go that small with surgery, i think all you need now is some fillers on your chin because you have weak chin.. but you results are amazing with or without filters and your nose is not large at all and it looks better than before
February 3, 2020

This comment was removed at the user's request

February 16, 2020
I agree with you. You don't have weak chin. You look fine before. You still look fine now. Maybe your nose takes longer to go down. Cartilages do resorb over time. I have read a few posts where others complain about how their bridge becomes lower after 6 months or a year or how the tip drops after a year. So hopefully, your nose will do the same. So maybe giving it another 6 months? You are still pretty as a whole, by the way.
March 4, 2020

This comment was removed at the user's request

April 23, 2020
I disagree about the fillers on the chin. The fillers on the chin may appear unnatural. I’m my opinion your chin is perfect please do not alter your chin.
April 23, 2020
In** my opinion.. Also, you are very beautiful. I’m sure you are very beautiful even without filter.
April 26, 2020
I just don’t get it, you clearly expressed what you wanted and he completely ignored your requests. It’s as if he just gave you a nose that he considers ideal, while completely ignoring what his patient asked for, absolutely ridiculous. He should seriously offer a revision to make up for his terrible mistake. I just don’t know if I would leave a revision up to somebody like him, someone who ignores what his patient is seeking. Maybe if he is a good doctor, he would at least offer to pay for your revision if he can’t fix it himself. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder so, I know some people may find your nose to be the perfect size and shape, but all of that doesn’t matter if you can’t be happy with the new nose. It just wouldn’t matter if a million people told you that you have a perfect nose, it would go in one ear and out the other. If you feel a smaller nose would balance out your features, I see that a revision can only improve your results. You must be repetitive in expressing what you want to the doctor. Sometimes, no matter how skilled the doctor may be, they have a stubborn point of view on what they consider beauty. You have to repeat to them, many times, as if they’re 5 years old, with detailed descriptions, of exactly what you want. The goal is to nail it in their heads, that sometimes in their career, they will have patients that do not share the same ideal of beauty that they consider aesthetically pleasing. Please, anyone who is considering surgery, do not trust a doctor 100% just because they are a doctor ( it doesn’t matter if they’re a world renowned doctor or how popular they are ). Don’t ever take cosmetic enhancements lightly. Please, do tons of research and find a doctor who gives the results that you guys are looking for, because that’s a sign that they have similar taste with you in what they consider to be visually pleasing.
March 5, 2020
How did your head scar heal? Is it still noticeable?